Navigating Plain City, Ohio: Everything to Know Before Making the Move
Check out this comprehensive guide to discover all things Plain City, Ohio!

Restaurants in Plain City, Ohio
Calling all gastronomists! Did you know that Plain City boasts some of the best restaurants in Central Ohio? Here are our top five picks for some of the tastiest spots the locals can’t stop raving about.
Der Dutchman
In Plain City, Ohio, Der Dutchman Restaurant is a famous all-in-one eatery, shop, market, and theater. This Amish-style establishment is a highly rated and sought-after destination for locals, visitors, and travelers alike. Stop by with your loved ones for the freshest food and a sweet treat. Der Dutchman Bakery will satisfy your sweet cravings no matter what you order.
Menu Favorites: Dutchman Burger, Roast Beef Dinner, Loaded Chopped Sirloin
The Red Hen Cafe & Bakery
The Red Hen Cafe & Bakery is a beloved local coffee shop and bakery that brings together a community with its delicious menu of cozy bites and quality coffee. This highly rated Plain City, Ohio, eatery is perfect for a casual and tasty brunch.
Menu Favorites: Croissant Sandwich, White Iced Cinnamon Roll, Maple Cinnamon Latte
The Grainery
Located in downtown Plain City, The Grainery serves slow-smoked meat, tacos, and craft beer in a vibrant atmosphere. This laid-back setting often hosts musical performances and events — it doesn’t get much better than this!
Menu Favorites: Loaded Nachos, Brisket Sandwich, Wagyu Chili Burger
City Barbeque
If you’re a barbecue lover, you’ve heard of City Barbeque. This counter-serve chain has a location in Plain City, where you’ll taste traditional barbecue delicacies, including an 18-hour smoked brisket. There’s no need to visit Texas when we’ve got some of the best barbecues right here in Plain City, Ohio.
Menu Favorites: Spicy Smokestack, Brisket Chili Bowl, Not a Sloppy Joe
Lee’s Sports & Spirits
Lee’s Sports & Spirits is the ultimate place for delicious food and lively energy. This laid-back sports bar serves classic American cuisine, hosts karaoke nights, and is a go-to top hang-out spot. Check out the website to view their upcoming special events.
Menu Favorites: Philly Cheesesteak Sub, Mushroom Swiss Burger, Steak Wrap
Things to Do in Plain City, Ohio
Plain City offers a variety of easy-going activities for the family. Here are some of our favorites!
Yutzy’s Farm Market
One of the best things to do in Plain City is shopping at Yutzy’s Farm Market. Here, you’ll find weekly specials of bulk Amish produce, cheeses, meats, and baked goods. Support local farmers and small businesses at one of the most popular markets in Central Ohio.
Address: 6010 Converse Huff Rd, Plain City, OH 43064
Pastime Park
Want an escape to the great outdoors? Pastime Park is a campground offering walking trails, disc golf, and an aquatic center. Plain City residents love spending a peaceful weekend getaway in this well-maintained campground. Trailer hookups are available, as well as more primitive campsites.
Address: 370 N Chillicothe St, Plain City, OH 43064
Old 42 Antiques & Vintage Marketplace
Old 42 Antiques & Vintage Marketplace is a charming little antique shop in Plain City, Ohio, where unique treasures await you every visit. Say hello to the live birds situated throughout the store, chirping sweetly as you shop. In this place, you’ll never know what you’ll find!
Address: 8690 US-42, Plain City, OH 43064
Carlisle Gifts Plain City
Part of the Der Dutchman family, Carlisle Gifts is located just steps from the bakery. This store offers trendy jewelry, fashionable handbags, home decor, and more. Whether you’re looking for a special gift or a stylish outfit, Carlisle Gifts is the perfect place to start.
Address: 445 Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Plain City Historical Society
Founded in 1982, the Plain City Historical Society preserves the city’s historical artifacts and memorabilia. The society’s museum and library house stunning artifacts that tell the rich story of Plain City. If you’re strolling through downtown, this Historical Society is well worth a visit.
Address: 105 W Main St, Plain City, OH 43064
Homes for Sale in Plain City, Ohio
Are you interested in relocating to Central Ohio? Plain City is a great place to start your new home search.
The Run at Hofbauer Preserve offers residents the ideal balance between suburban charm and city convenience. The community’s beautiful homes are nestled within lush, natural landscapes. You’ll be just minutes from nearby parks like Glacier Ridge Metro Park, perfect for relaxing nature walks, community events, and fun family outings. The Run at Hofbauer Preserve is also conveniently located within minutes of Dublin and Marysville and is a short commute to downtown Columbus.
The community is also within the Jonathan Alder School District, known for its connectedness, dedication to athletics, anti-bullying stance, and quality academics.
Plain City is for you!
Plain City is a wonderful village in Columbus, giving residents a perfect balance between city life and suburban living. If you’re ready to make your move and discover all Plain City has to offer, contact us today! We can’t wait to help you find your dream home.