Your Guide to the Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus, Ohio

Did you know that the great city of Columbus has deep Italian roots that have heavily influenced its culture? Named after the Italian explorer Christopher Columbus, the city’s architecture, festivals, and Italian village celebrate its European roots – and that’s just the start. Columbus’s Italian cuisine will instantly teleport you to Italy with just one bite.

Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

Discovering all the things to do in Columbus works up an appetite. Why not try the highly esteemed Italian restaurants to satisfy your hunger? With countless restaurants in this city, we’re spotlighting the best Italian restaurants in Columbus, Ohio. Grab your napkins and forks, and explore our top picks below.

Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria

Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria is a small mom-and-pop shop that serves up some of the best traditional Italian food in the greater Columbus area. Along with fan-favorite pasta and seafood entrees, this family business also owns a bakery, so expect decadent baked goods and desserts.

Menu Favorites: Pasta Fritto, Wedding Soup, Gnocchi

Villa Nova Ristorante

Another family-owned restaurant, Villa Nova Ristorante, is a laid-back eatery specializing in Italian and American fare. Established in 1978, this small-town gem caters, hosts events, and accommodates parties. Don’t miss out on their happy hour specials!

Menu Favorites: Fried Calamari, Spaghetti Carbonara, Lasagna

Marcella’s

Marcella’s is a lively Southern Italian kitchen that’s perfect for a fun night out. Locals and visitors rave about the happy hour here, often considering it one of Columbus’s best destinations for drinks and appetizers. Try it for yourself!

Menu Favorites: Burrata, Gnocchi con Bolognese, Risotto

Gallo’s Kitchen & Bar

Gallo’s Kitchen & Bar is a casual bar serving Italian and Creole cuisine. With consistently high reviews, visitors often vote this one of the best Italian restaurants in Columbus, Ohio. With mouthwatering food, lively environment, and plenty of big screen TVs, you’ll never be disappointed at Gallo’s Kitchen & Bar.</p> <p><strong>Menu Favorites:</strong> Arancini, Cavatelli Alfredo, Grilled Creole Chicken Sandwich</p> <h3>Martini Modern Italian</h3> <p>Introducing <a href=” https:=”” martinimodernitalian=”” com=”” target=”_blank” martini=”” modern=”” italian=”” a=”” rel=”noopener”>, where traditional Italian cuisine meets contemporary flare. This upscale restaurant serves creative interpretations of traditional food patrons can’t get enough of. Make sure to book a reservation in advance.

Menu Favorites: Arancini, Chicken Carbonara, Veal Martini

Carfagna’s Ristorante

Part restaurant and part Italian market, Carfagna’s Ristorante delivers exceptional traditional pasta, pizza, and other fare in a full-bar setting. Dine in for an immersive culinary experience, and then shop at the market for the freshest ingredients. This all-in-one experience makes Carfagna’s Ristorante one of the best Italian restaurants in Columbus, Ohio.

Menu Favorites: Burrata Caprese, Chicken Parm Sandwich, Baked Ziti

The Spaghetti Warehouse

The Spaghetti Warehouse is a casual Italian chain specializing in your favorite pasta dishes and hand-crafted cocktails. Channeling modern Italian cuisine, this community favorite is suitable for a full-course family meal or an easygoing brunch with a friend. With a new location on South High Street, The Spaghetti Warehouse will soon be your vibrant go-to spot!

Menu Favorites: Chicken Florentine, 15-Layer Lasagna, Four Cheese Ravioli

Ciao For Now!

We’ve only just scratched the surface of Columbus’s selection of mouthwatering Italian restaurants. If you’re curious about what else Columbus has to offer, then check out our blog for more ideas on exploring the city. You won’t be disappointed!